对盟军环礁登岛战役的实验

黑豹G

实验场地：环礁岛屿萨塔瓦尔Satawal、9级城防、盟军从沃勒爱Wuleai出发。7 }/ v1 g, ^! `) D5 Q
实验兵力：盟军18个师    陆战1、2、3、4师，第3、6、7、24、25、27、30、37、40、41、43步兵师，骑1师，
7 I4 ]4 P: [- B% c1 S                 亚美利加师，澳大利亚第6师。   第18、19、47战斗工兵团，11个坦克营，17个炮兵团，中太平洋司令部，/ c/ S8 d4 g0 ~6 {1 W
                 美第6集团军，美第3，9，10军。3 A* k# |8 g" U' u( Z* i
                 日军兵力 吴镇守府第1、2陆战队，第44、62、63、64海警队，日本陆军132基地部队，第33军司令部。
- q8 }! {$ }" e$ r; e* W4 _战斗过程：由盟军22艘CV轰炸3天，登陆当天16艘BB分两队进行炮击。
" ]5 S/ q, a0 x. W- d4 a& t战斗评价：重锤砸鸡蛋，毫无悬念，3支部队直接被歼灭，战斗工兵将城防直接从9降到3。
( F$ p4 K; S1 Y' V- C战斗报告：Ground combat at Satawal( ^1 B0 A: d" c4 O" X

7 _; d5 D) V- Z& A4 m2 k5 C. p                  Allied Shock attack! \. I# Q0 K( `7 e! u, T
% V9 \6 E' ^0 b
                  Attacking force 230295 troops, 2040 guns, 548 vehicles, Assault Value = 5624# g/ U; e' E( J: [  q
7 C8 H; H3 n3 }& A
                  Defending force 23017 troops, 45 guns, 0 vehicles, Assault Value = 587
9 y  Z  `- r' R$ Q+ z# q
) ~+ {) \" M$ K+ A. l                  Allied engineers reduce fortifications to 3- m: k- z" H( R
; k' `! L0 T' w9 l. h
                  Allied max assault: 8784 - adjusted assault: 4806
- {6 M! P* |0 l
7 y% D7 E; E' s" K" ^2 z                  Japanese max defense: 381 - adjusted defense: 95 4 \" @1 v( _0 Q9 I
3 [; X3 N- a1 v. q4 v
                  Allied assault odds: 50 to 1 (fort level 3) 8 d8 o) ~; |2 ]" a

6 p0 \, k9 `+ Y8 a0 z- H                  Allied forces CAPTURE Satawal base !!!
$ }7 I( Z7 a" L# [) C' U1 v' f+ `$ @( `: b, [" O

6 ~* n( g( H: l2 P  h& W+ L                  Japanese ground losses:7 @. X7 ~: d5 Z. G, o
                  5806 casualties reported; }2 z1 t! A, ^0 z% i0 A" c* i2 b
                  Guns lost 309 C- R( G/ @2 M5 W0 F8 q9 o- i+ I
; K  G) B0 m$ q$ p/ J* s3 K3 c0 X+ ?" o
                  Allied ground losses:
' m5 |0 e) {+ O* ]: e& `                  5263 casualties reported$ j# P9 @0 C5 r1 k6 q, O# [! M, C
                  Guns lost 128; X) K# d3 w3 J% b+ q7 u
                  Vehicles lost 86& p# L' w8 p! l* d1 J' c
+ _% c, x. H1 o  P
[ 本帖最后由 黑豹G 于 2007-12-4 19:20 编辑 ]

黑豹G

盟军兵力减少，为陆战1、2、3、4师，澳大利亚第6师，全部的装甲和辅助部队，火力准备不变。
! w# U5 K* }; h' z战斗结果：
9 l( E: D* P& D: iGround combat at Satawal
/ v( x( l* }8 ~8 H
* l2 z1 Y* h" S! z: w8 JAllied Shock attack
- G$ Q6 R. v3 h* \1 ~2 ]1 L/ e
. ^$ g  {4 \% N; n- S2 x5 eAttacking force 77949 troops, 685 guns, 548 vehicles, Assault Value = 2044. c. C7 g8 ?- X- o/ \+ r
( {" M+ e' t  M- E. L. z) p/ d
Defending force 23408 troops, 58 guns, 0 vehicles, Assault Value = 590
/ z# t! t, M& P( B; [- D/ J ; h" ~/ N& O' H& }4 X. e
Allied engineers reduce fortifications to 7  ~2 V. \( S! |3 O/ s' e6 R8 K
3 n* N$ {3 m: r- {: j) |
Allied max assault: 3322 - adjusted assault: 983 - c5 P6 ]8 [$ W
( v8 h. \1 O4 z5 |8 k8 C5 b
Japanese max defense: 389 - adjusted defense: 195 6 R" Z1 d+ T. _4 R8 @% W1 A
& l+ A* k! h9 {: h( T
Allied assault odds: 5 to 1 (fort level 7)
# @8 c: X3 t* J. r* R/ ~1 a  J
2 C3 J; t" i- g* h: g" SAllied Assault reduces fortifications to 4
4 U. ~0 W2 j" h7 z0 V9 U * Z' ]* _5 ]) v8 Y
! x4 k7 Q  m4 P
Japanese ground losses:! `  Q5 g! ?  H
3589 casualties reported; R6 ?5 w. m) z' ], h: B9 e
Guns lost 45- R2 }* f* Q6 X6 b9 s) D3 ~. x
" @  w$ o. r5 o0 [, R/ q
Allied ground losses:
8 L4 e0 a1 m- K9 d1 v9 L& n) q3650 casualties reported/ H& @& C; [! a( j: z8 w! I
Guns lost 57% U+ _5 Z# _9 W7 A+ x" [
Vehicles lost 106( @7 M! K8 i2 I, S' ~3 K+ a" G# _

' q+ \/ e% q9 e# R8 g第二天攻克该岛。

hades1001

建议增加师团级单位继续测试

黑豹G

盟军兵力再次减少，仅由陆战1、2、3、4师发动进攻，由6个炮兵团提供辅助，火力准备依然不变。
: K; s# {5 e! }' A( _. dGround combat at Satawal" O: Q  [+ [$ P7 |
; ~5 L6 Z, W/ U: W7 K  S" v
Allied Shock attack) I! C7 p( e9 l% i& W0 I( I0 U
+ b2 E% _* u& H6 T
Attacking force 58266 troops, 569 guns, 45 vehicles, Assault Value = 1347
/ r3 d5 B* G) P( i& m/ X; u
2 V4 t) e9 p! |( N# c" f) oDefending force 24428 troops, 58 guns, 0 vehicles, Assault Value = 601% G" S$ a; h  ^6 k

& e' K4 T* v9 q4 f: d+ y; \. kAllied engineers reduce fortifications to 8( q% L* y2 f6 s& u1 h9 B! m
. \0 n4 h/ m  q
Allied max assault: 2290 - adjusted assault: 716 7 ^3 C1 N) o8 E, `4 K& b1 R) R5 U

% e+ ^) R4 A. S0 ?# b* sJapanese max defense: 426 - adjusted defense: 383 8 S4 Q, E9 y; d/ e' r4 j

" d* w  N/ R: _. ]Allied assault odds: 1 to 1 (fort level 8) ; _6 C. A" U& S, j- H1 t9 J

6 P& x/ \" }! F+ F" V& RAllied Assault reduces fortifications to 85 k5 K* R1 h; M
: @4 N3 z( t4 H5 E
7 ~; {" h6 _/ a  }: ^0 V  j
Japanese ground losses:
3 z: d; n# ], @) b: `& U3041 casualties reported
% L( K$ I; q1 a. N  ]Guns lost 31
) V. a; {1 g8 U2 N# R 7 n& A) |7 V* `! \- S! q+ W: f; [2 }
Allied ground losses:
9 a8 a- _/ N" \1 K( L3144 casualties reported6 I2 d# _/ d+ T, ~  P
Guns lost 57, S! E- v: t* [- m+ X1 C
Vehicles lost 19) _0 H# Z0 W9 C
+ D/ @& P/ M, u  W& x, m
由此可见，对付上述兵力的日军守备队，此兵力为临界点。

黑豹G

由近卫师团（451战斗力）替换4个海警队（432战斗力），岛上战斗力基本维持不变。

黑豹G

战斗结果大大出乎预料。
. r  I! B! F( V0 H6 E美军4个师：陆战3、4师，第6、25步兵师和全部的炮工坦部队，一次突击就拿下了该岛
, _  r. V  H0 a% e, |, LGround combat at Satawal; q* c  `: ]6 {6 k( d+ a
; y# Z5 _0 k) Q( ^. s& m2 a
Allied Shock attack; j4 e# f- w& }
8 y. u/ R% a  e# M: G
Attacking force 63995 troops, 555 guns, 530 vehicles, Assault Value = 1600
/ R2 e) {6 ^" @+ f  j% H, ?9 y + s$ Z1 d" G3 z, r/ t6 O1 [' ~
Defending force 32850 troops, 291 guns, 0 vehicles, Assault Value = 660
" U4 l' @" l, m; ]2 S/ g2 [ " s4 j0 V3 t& N, Q
Allied max assault: 3266 - adjusted assault: 1518 8 E3 T7 ~5 ?, O

2 J2 w+ u0 Z3 A( d- r' @! y" fJapanese max defense: 359 - adjusted defense: 106 % y* B" y9 S" s  \" b2 O+ N% a$ X

" J/ T, E0 P6 p4 ^Allied assault odds: 14 to 1 (fort level 9)
1 @) n0 s5 E) k4 d$ _+ X/ E
+ E5 Q4 l2 S- p7 H1 J# yAllied forces CAPTURE Satawal base !!!
, B. U( p% I2 g1 ^7 p ( T4 j  E. A  n4 j  s
* r( L3 D1 o4 }4 ]
Japanese ground losses:, o# @6 a3 E( ^$ }: ^+ Q, }
2875 casualties reported
3 a: _) |; T8 p( A) h; p0 r9 ^  L/ YGuns lost 47! I4 s0 d8 \; z" ^

% L/ a: s# ]! ?Allied ground losses:
+ s7 a* P; d9 T& E: _. ^2742 casualties reported
( \! Z2 Z  L1 J" `1 RGuns lost 50
& T" M% h/ `9 X, U; TVehicles lost 71

reninhat

看来500+坦克，的确厉害

黑豹G

使用和第二次实验完全相同的兵力，结果表明，近卫师团发挥实在欠佳 1 Z% k% |& v3 w& h3 \; l: o) N* f  u
$ E" U( k* i7 n4 w/ i; {
Ground combat at Satawal) \! ^8 k6 q+ M* z* N2 @0 N7 U+ a

, d6 e$ t: [" gAllied Shock attack  d- g/ p7 a! {
8 z1 W+ o/ Y  h& A% y% n
Attacking force 77120 troops, 685 guns, 540 vehicles, Assault Value = 2046
& Y4 z5 \3 T3 m% }  ^( Y: ]
+ L: c# T8 T" H9 ?, L, I" IDefending force 35166 troops, 292 guns, 0 vehicles, Assault Value = 695- i& t- e5 F9 k! s& f
# e* C' j: ~( C$ P
Allied engineers reduce fortifications to 8  |7 s3 P, P/ r8 K9 ]

3 O" [! x, ^$ b4 I( L) WAllied max assault: 3770 - adjusted assault: 1764 - I/ [( |/ |/ b4 f$ e+ _

+ e# i3 _7 f5 N& i. sJapanese max defense: 395 - adjusted defense: 126
6 s9 `# V$ J' c2 M3 r4 h5 i; f 6 E/ K& v/ P+ E8 V7 H
Allied assault odds: 14 to 1 (fort level 8)
  F) ?$ G5 U& t0 y/ A - F4 F; v" q7 C% Y  t) s
Allied forces CAPTURE Satawal base !!!  z/ G7 m9 O# }, o1 ~$ l" m  Z
4 T# q/ A4 O$ V- V6 c7 H, G
  _8 |: c1 f7 m. `
Japanese ground losses:  t! _7 `4 H' k7 m0 k
4971 casualties reported
1 U5 W' w4 [! D3 zGuns lost 64
% D, w4 d/ N8 D. T% B2 @, j5 e  A 6 H. _: J* `+ r& P9 ~
Allied ground losses:
' M$ K2 @6 l- l' `7 C1430 casualties reported
4 L2 W% z% z- `  s& J7 hGuns lost 69
5 `0 n: ^8 g5 g( dVehicles lost 66

黑豹G

盟军去掉了坦克部队，为平衡计，新投入了亚美利加师和41步兵师，结果一样把近卫师团打得满地找牙……4 E5 W0 N; h3 ]6 j" a
Ground combat at Satawal
5 ~' n8 a. m1 F3 e2 l; E6 B
& R% `$ W3 [, ^Allied Shock attack
& n* Y& R. d; L. @( f / c! D+ R5 W5 P+ t% @) d
Attacking force 84239 troops, 828 guns, 44 vehicles, Assault Value = 1942
- b$ i0 V* I- o5 \, D2 }# H* b' _' x
+ C0 d* E& o( h2 tDefending force 35202 troops, 265 guns, 0 vehicles, Assault Value = 6950 b  C: O. d* l" ~
0 k' C1 Z! x3 w" }! b- g1 |& p
Allied engineers reduce fortifications to 7
/ o4 c# K: J/ U+ f& W ' t( O4 }) W# Z' E
Allied max assault: 3412 - adjusted assault: 1394
, G$ W4 ?$ p: n: p ' X# Y( s, C3 q% F
Japanese max defense: 413 - adjusted defense: 165 1 s( X4 P6 i* i0 I; T

2 m$ B8 T. F, u! O9 C/ o5 l2 lAllied assault odds: 8 to 1 (fort level 7)
: [# k. v; F2 B9 A' M2 R
, E! A- ?1 U+ {! L2 g4 c) wAllied Assault reduces fortifications to 1
8 E7 }. r, G) U1 j5 }. u
0 G) C5 Z2 p$ Z: l& E* a 6 b5 L+ U! {4 Q& L) T( \# R4 @
Japanese ground losses:6 Q+ Q% w$ o0 N+ }( }
3652 casualties reported
& k+ p8 i  _: lGuns lost 55
9 J5 d( J1 b* F" w; z$ T
3 O" |8 @8 ?8 aAllied ground losses:
* Y8 w5 l5 d1 m& b) B2 K6 U' S5 L3429 casualties reported9 M4 v6 C; L5 ?9 E' M7 b% c
Guns lost 94
/ V# c& s$ [! q: l( _* HVehicles lost 11

黑豹G

加入第1岸炮联队

蔷薇骑士团

靠
! b% P& f7 {6 b/ s居然这么离谱！这下日军的放血战术也搞不下去了，都不知道是在放谁的血 2 H6 ]) Z' I5 O4 S+ }4 v. ^" _
太可悲了

黑豹G

使用和第六次完全相同的兵力。
( W7 O* X% a2 c登陆部队被岸炮打击非常严重。
1 H2 [  X# O2 B$ [7 hCoastal Guns at Satawal, 60,74, firing at TF 1005
- D) g% {2 Z" E) p( O6 ~9 l9 GTF 1005 troops unloading over beach at Satawal, 60,74
* F1 ^1 Z( [# c" C# n1 `( y8 h 2 Q' V3 N  q( @9 K" b

( n7 r2 ], W$ g1 H1782 Coastal gun shots fired in defense.
, F1 t9 P9 P& \; LAllied Ships
1 ?, s, F: t; l* F: VAO Schuylkill, Shell hits 6,  on fire
# ]1 {2 `0 R" v) GAO Saugatuck, Shell hits 14,  on fire; K" H" e4 c: \
AK Cetus, Shell hits 3,  on fire
8 N) ]# ]9 s8 t* PAK Cassiopeia, Shell hits 1
# b" S# ?5 p8 s3 f4 u% eAO Saranac, Shell hits 14,  on fire,  heavy damage0 T. _4 d$ i% L' O
AO Suamico, Shell hits 6,  on fire# B; U. A* c6 [
AO Taluga, Shell hits 15,  on fire,  heavy damage& g+ O, A/ U& o- c9 P9 Z5 M/ s
AK PT-24, Shell hits 18,  on fire,  heavy damage
, z/ F' z1 ~3 {) }* kAK Alshain, Shell hits 15,  on fire,  heavy damage' r, u, d* b. s' p+ u& a
AGP Mobjack, Shell hits 9,  on fire,  heavy damage
. E7 F0 i: t8 {0 n% s1 rAK Virgo, Shell hits 5,  on fire,  heavy damage; m1 |9 i" N+ F/ \. f
AK Alkes, Shell hits 12,  on fire
+ p% E0 q8 T* n6 N: nAK Allioth, Shell hits 4,  on fire0 W% |' H- d" Y1 `) G
AS Clytie, Shell hits 10,  on fire,  heavy damage
0 |- e" x2 H1 C+ Z % I1 a+ f, C0 U& i. r
1 l) M" x4 b9 x$ i
Allied ground losses:% t3 z: l: n0 K* b" R( ~
10243 casualties reported
$ `! ^& F+ J: S+ U! }Guns lost 33( A* C& y: l1 D  G

8 K7 ]9 J4 L( i# ?- z8 rCoastal Guns at Satawal, 60,74, firing at TF 10023 u  z: T  z) w# a% ?
TF 1002 troops unloading over beach at Satawal, 60,74
2 Y1 O' f& f) X) i2 I
7 I$ u: T/ m. z" N
" K7 N0 c9 @$ |# |$ n393 Coastal gun shots fired in defense.
; ~' m8 a# ?6 p3 w/ R; NAllied Ships
: h) F4 ^( b. q: d) h6 h( \DMS Long
0 s# m4 r* }7 i$ f( gLST LST-207, Shell hits 8,  on fire,  heavy damage
& g* q, r. o: ?7 ?. @& HDMS Hopkins, Shell hits 5,  on fire,  heavy damage
" }8 D! o9 y9 w5 a9 USC SC-1064, Shell hits 9,  on fire,  heavy damage; g6 U- G  D' E  T* Y7 Y+ t
LST LST-125
& Y" x  ?" k6 B/ V% _* B; GSC SC-1063, Shell hits 3,  on fire,  heavy damage: H; M5 Q/ [- s" V
LST LST-123, Shell hits 19,  on fire,  heavy damage2 c  ^0 [9 c2 o( m" W6 n
LST LST-40, Shell hits 6,  on fire,  heavy damage$ x3 @6 x* z( ?) K
SC SC-739, Shell hits 7,  on fire,  heavy damage
0 p9 Y5 q9 m' `* i/ aLST LST-21, Shell hits 24,  on fire,  heavy damage
8 k5 i8 x' ]) ~5 x 9 x% {* `1 X: Z& K0 |

: m) Z# i% i3 ]Allied ground losses:
8 c/ y+ d' g) |& Z% y0 q% C7403 casualties reported
5 Y2 B/ @- D* \7 s6 OGuns lost 53
. C3 Q+ G" K% l7 r- j0 c& f* h
4 x1 n) u$ w/ o# q; \但是近卫师团依然发挥不理想
/ r& K1 j7 ^+ A4 M4 [, ZGround combat at Satawal" {+ Z  [1 k! K
7 D3 T, z* {2 ~# }4 E' p: G
Allied Shock attack3 c3 K4 i6 m# K3 M" E2 w5 Z3 Z

' T! I9 J" X2 G( h5 LAttacking force 76608 troops, 763 guns, 51 vehicles, Assault Value = 1841
6 |' n/ E7 p! Q . S; u# H3 I6 ~% f6 x
Defending force 37275 troops, 335 guns, 0 vehicles, Assault Value = 6900 Z) g1 i& n/ D2 I* ^9 i

! S9 i% I. d  N6 _& mAllied max assault: 3382 - adjusted assault: 1310 1 i9 G, B0 h4 O7 ~
+ |4 N0 v" y0 U8 E% i5 K
Japanese max defense: 458 - adjusted defense: 142
, W5 Y$ Y" e5 g+ {) ]+ D 1 {  Q) ]6 f. q2 y9 R& G. Q
Allied assault odds: 8 to 1 (fort level 9)
5 U$ p: x7 t  f+ y, @" ^7 c9 w3 s * U' J5 o3 A1 M" V! m% f
Allied Assault reduces fortifications to 2
! i. ]# n7 @, U$ b5 E
( B1 B$ R0 o7 a* Y+ s( N
3 a2 U/ y7 b: I3 p! X: ]Japanese ground losses:
: T7 q5 l8 p5 X! i" i2 S+ c  A6 A3894 casualties reported
6 i# W2 l. g; ~9 H' |; OGuns lost 75. K, W+ F& s, D5 z; Z# a6 [& n6 S

/ ~& F$ \* `$ i2 U1 L+ k  b1 \0 ]3 eAllied ground losses:% ]! U! Z6 v0 z# c+ h0 c. U
3278 casualties reported0 ~- h% Z; G+ y; m0 j
Guns lost 82
- d6 `* {+ x+ ~& a/ g7 [. {Vehicles lost 20

Donnie_Brasco

日军才一个师团么，多放两个美军还不得吐血。

黑豹G

第2岸炮联队投入

reninhat

近卫师团的经验和士气多少？