ANDY准备投降了？0 [& v9 S% Z n4 X( m3 t. D
0 O1 G6 X- [, C! D) x% R
Hi yes I have about 40 subs in Tinian waters and approaches but they are doing limited good.4 T" w4 W+ c3 l* k: r9 r, t
8 N8 o: O# |& s
OK today I only got 0:1 so its game over on Tinian.1 Y! z5 X; k6 e- |6 Q
9 U3 M/ g0 y5 s* R" _" \; XOK a few points for everyone thank you for the email questions but its easier to answer them on the forum en masse so to speak.
0 w1 V# }5 z' ~) z6 R
- [+ G& K" g3 _; b% s1 ]If I miss anyones questions apologies+ f7 P$ J, S f& A- Q/ j9 o
& j, \9 j$ S! W3 \6 H* b
1. Why did you attack Tinian and not another island in the Marianas.3 N2 y1 }- M; B6 v
- ?2 i& E: K* z- ~9 TAll other islands are mountainous so Tinian has a x 4 AV multiple for forts, Saipan, Guam or Pagan would have x 12 because forts and mountains are mutiplactive. i.e. attacking the Marianas for the allies is a no choice option.! M* V8 q# V. Q& ~
/ U* T4 Z3 p& W/ |+ h2. Why did you not bomb before attacking.+ t. i' l! j8 R( P. S
7 j- m* f9 s6 g0 o9 Y* ?Because it is not possible in WITP to interdict land reinforcements if the Japanese player is willing to take the losses he can put 2 or 3 Divs ashore in short order either by transport aircraft or massed AK invasion - Pauk did that to me at Gasmata so he knows the moves and PZB has completed it many times another 1,000 AV x 4 = no matter what the allies bring its not possible.3 F# i8 Q; c( w
0 F* V! |8 ?& `- a$ r5 {3. Why did you not sweep the mines before landing ?: G3 Y, Y9 I; o
$ h, C7 T" A/ ^% K; s; qOver 40 MSWs were destroyed int he first hour of the fight despite having DD and BB support int he same TF.
3 w8 D: a: l) }. r6 T$ X
7 i% d1 i4 q }8 a. G$ @1 |4. Why did you give up on SWPAC, }" n0 J1 }) u8 t; |
6 P$ u( I! H7 Z5 v
SWPAC is a valid attack route BUT with every base having lvl 9 forts and the Japanese able to reinforce and it being malaria it is a VERY tough attack route. Remember Noemfoor against PZB a single Bde can stop 2 - 3 Divs of allied Troops for a long time. Forts are just to strong in jungle and Malaria.
X0 _% r2 I( [* o
* u2 k* c7 F- } j2 H; d5. Why not attack Marcus, m @ ?2 R2 M6 z+ t! Q
. F# L; _7 q8 }9 z+ ]5 XPerhaps I should have valid question
u7 |3 K2 W9 s/ b5 w# ?
3 } m3 ]/ V. V) t4 K" `6. Why not attack HI/ F# f4 m7 A+ R1 ?6 f6 h; A% O* d
- ^ U3 M* T& q1 l& FBecause although I would have won it would have left a bad taste in the mouth.
/ F( ~' |3 h4 _" d7 k& L. }8 y5 S1 I3 u& P1 \4 H
OK what now - honest answer I dont know' o2 e0 C9 Q0 ]5 j4 V3 Y1 ^
Andy |
发表于 2007-9-18 17:45
| 
: H5 S9 x) r4 h1 L/ V0 m0 V
; x Q; v7 H* d. g l. r3 l
发表于 2007-9-18 21:08
| 
要独立对抗KB(至今只损失1条CVE!)+12BB(可能大和在修)+无数陆航 唉
加油 盟军!
!
# ?+ D/ a1 V: g5 V