ANDY准备投降了？" L2 N& {" p$ c+ g$ o" H
- Z# N/ J9 O) s w' bHi yes I have about 40 subs in Tinian waters and approaches but they are doing limited good.
" o3 ~5 n/ r T
# {7 E! }1 R/ f0 y9 x0 `7 E# X5 MOK today I only got 0:1 so its game over on Tinian.+ X% K' N% O1 A/ A* ~
$ L. q0 G8 q8 @* ~
OK a few points for everyone thank you for the email questions but its easier to answer them on the forum en masse so to speak.
: k% {3 l( s/ b$ x0 x y l/ j, U% R) Q
If I miss anyones questions apologies
5 J& j; ?: m8 Z& O1 z/ l6 B& l: r! Q* D: s0 s3 _5 J
1. Why did you attack Tinian and not another island in the Marianas.
8 A V* |" d9 }% h
) f9 O% L! Z6 @( T) F. zAll other islands are mountainous so Tinian has a x 4 AV multiple for forts, Saipan, Guam or Pagan would have x 12 because forts and mountains are mutiplactive. i.e. attacking the Marianas for the allies is a no choice option.5 I% }% P2 y4 c: C, e: f7 T" N6 W
. Y- ]) q3 {7 T, \/ E
2. Why did you not bomb before attacking.( D. I5 J. |. A1 Q
% F( P& j, V2 L) ?; z
Because it is not possible in WITP to interdict land reinforcements if the Japanese player is willing to take the losses he can put 2 or 3 Divs ashore in short order either by transport aircraft or massed AK invasion - Pauk did that to me at Gasmata so he knows the moves and PZB has completed it many times another 1,000 AV x 4 = no matter what the allies bring its not possible.
3 d8 ~9 m- p9 \/ i' _6 x
2 J) G# ^' x( g( g$ t9 b3. Why did you not sweep the mines before landing ?
/ ~2 \& E! U+ M( K6 r: q) q& @; ~$ {% t# ^- G! \. Q" y x' R
Over 40 MSWs were destroyed int he first hour of the fight despite having DD and BB support int he same TF.
4 o% h, i- }9 x* M' A* w. \ X) R" v! G l
4. Why did you give up on SWPAC
) b1 d) O3 S' P9 C
4 Z5 Y( r v2 s1 f" J8 i' YSWPAC is a valid attack route BUT with every base having lvl 9 forts and the Japanese able to reinforce and it being malaria it is a VERY tough attack route. Remember Noemfoor against PZB a single Bde can stop 2 - 3 Divs of allied Troops for a long time. Forts are just to strong in jungle and Malaria.
9 ~! n9 f. n* X5 {. i, u& v" J* N7 ^6 k. S
5. Why not attack Marcus& ^# Y4 n3 o$ c1 H. s) E
8 C/ V& |, W& s$ F, Q& K
Perhaps I should have valid question
$ C2 J7 W+ I7 [0 f
) I- {4 Q* T2 P/ t2 W/ `6. Why not attack HI4 \5 N6 q4 O9 m- \- N
/ H* B% C$ p; T2 zBecause although I would have won it would have left a bad taste in the mouth.7 `# d6 G9 t. I8 P1 c, A
1 y8 p: e5 N: W+ uOK what now - honest answer I dont know
) C6 n: z* G5 A/ \1 ^* GAndy |
发表于 2007-9-18 17:45
| 
$ t: G; W7 u8 R( Q- ` M
/ n. k7 y; W+ y6 t( W8 H7 J
发表于 2007-9-18 21:08
| 
要独立对抗KB(至今只损失1条CVE!)+12BB(可能大和在修)+无数陆航 唉
加油 盟军!' s2 @' V9 X0 V
!
( _9 M2 p9 ~% y- r9 x. ^
