ANDY准备投降了？) q) p0 W, s, d2 L
0 q" h3 \6 f& l" v. V
Hi yes I have about 40 subs in Tinian waters and approaches but they are doing limited good.
+ C! r" R: x2 N+ o2 M# k+ ] O/ J" ]; C7 S
OK today I only got 0:1 so its game over on Tinian.
7 S' @+ n; J' |/ a) G6 r) [/ x% D
OK a few points for everyone thank you for the email questions but its easier to answer them on the forum en masse so to speak.
# m# L$ Q! x2 Z8 x) d
/ Y/ j8 |% v+ Y% ^& u6 i yIf I miss anyones questions apologies
( l1 r) s, F7 }% l, I' X3 w- T8 f* C4 n: C: [, l
1. Why did you attack Tinian and not another island in the Marianas.4 M; m* c0 W( n: t
J: C* B- A( H- R% p. l" x# r
All other islands are mountainous so Tinian has a x 4 AV multiple for forts, Saipan, Guam or Pagan would have x 12 because forts and mountains are mutiplactive. i.e. attacking the Marianas for the allies is a no choice option.6 e. C" `# k0 @ M
5 O% e! r% G& x, Y! Y2. Why did you not bomb before attacking./ l' l9 o( k0 C' E7 H+ }
0 R) E! F4 f$ c% h' oBecause it is not possible in WITP to interdict land reinforcements if the Japanese player is willing to take the losses he can put 2 or 3 Divs ashore in short order either by transport aircraft or massed AK invasion - Pauk did that to me at Gasmata so he knows the moves and PZB has completed it many times another 1,000 AV x 4 = no matter what the allies bring its not possible.
$ {7 r( [) p5 D5 j1 W/ k* f, ^/ ]8 Q! h& E% u
3. Why did you not sweep the mines before landing ?
* |. ~3 t {5 T( q4 \: K4 u6 M/ t' T* l: n$ G V$ a
Over 40 MSWs were destroyed int he first hour of the fight despite having DD and BB support int he same TF.6 L- h# J) V# r( ~7 ]6 I7 S
, ]( i) V7 [- N0 _- N
4. Why did you give up on SWPAC
+ ]8 s1 W* c& i1 a+ \- z
, t# i1 \# p9 g1 [3 ZSWPAC is a valid attack route BUT with every base having lvl 9 forts and the Japanese able to reinforce and it being malaria it is a VERY tough attack route. Remember Noemfoor against PZB a single Bde can stop 2 - 3 Divs of allied Troops for a long time. Forts are just to strong in jungle and Malaria.1 g$ J8 g& ` f" I G% G
4 Q2 P$ P1 q% z7 \) @3 d
5. Why not attack Marcus2 ^2 e( ]8 E, s2 M" T
: }* L8 l0 d8 ~ N& ?. pPerhaps I should have valid question
, a9 H x* h3 `5 p. Q) d- t: b* v) l' N8 r7 S' \) l& B# G5 E
6. Why not attack HI. }3 q y9 j5 ^- f
- E9 ^0 Z, w& |2 F2 k. ^$ b
Because although I would have won it would have left a bad taste in the mouth.: j/ v `% Y! b! H: f" S% Q- g
' r. d1 o' U9 v. C/ }' ROK what now - honest answer I dont know& @! x y4 @2 `% Y) w
Andy |
发表于 2007-9-18 17:45
| 
, `9 s! K( E3 h! x5 S
发表于 2007-9-18 21:08
| 
要独立对抗KB(至今只损失1条CVE!)+12BB(可能大和在修)+无数陆航 唉
加油 盟军!
!
